Ms. Gardner has written about theater and music for The New York Times, The…
The journey of David and Tally is full of twists that can be funny or horrifying — or both at once. An excellent Babak Tafti and a fearless Jodi Balfour bring these most unconventional characters to life.
Four actors, all female or non-binary, portray very young men in the Tony Award winner’s off-Broadway production, which marks the play’s American premiere.
While this production benefits greatly from the presence of actress Noma Dumezweni, it makes its points through often plodding dialogue that does a disservice both to its director, Warren Adams, and his game, accomplished cast.
Under Sarna Lapine’s direction, Smart seems curiously small and dim, as if she’s as oppressed by the material as her character is by her predicament. In the end, Jamie Wax’s play inspires pity more than empathy.
Unfortunately, the playwright’s distinctive blend of irreverence and whimsy isn’t as finely tuned as it has been for some other projects, and the results can seem self-indulgent and silly.
The actor finds humor in his character’s cluelessness and self-pity, sustaining a breezy, ironically cheerful vibe through much of a production that is likely to shake you to your core.
© 2025 The New York Sun Company, LLC. All rights reserved.
Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The material on this site is protected by copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used.